I wrote a short answer last night on this question shortly before going to bed. When I got up this morning to edit the answer to add details, it had been migrated to a comment. It was a short answer, so fine, I understand.

What puzzles me is that there was no alert showing in my stackexchange inbox. Why? If this is a known issue, then it should probably be standard practice to tag the user in another comment to alert them to the change.


There is a comment explaining it, but I'm wondering if it shouldn't have an @username in it to alert the user who posted it. Makes sense.


The answer was flagged, suggesting that it was more appropriate as a comment. I hit the button to do that. Your current answer changed the comment to a full blown answer which has already been accepted as best. I don't know how the alerts work in this process.


I figured it out with the help of a coworker who is a moderator on another SE site. It looks like there would have been an alert sent when the post was flagged as low-quality.

The moderator action of converting to a comment did delete the original post. At that point when the post was deleted, the alert of the comment from the flag was removed from the inbox.

I assume that someone felt the behavior of removing alerts when a moderator takes an action that deletes a post was desirable. It was confusing, but no big deal.

This site is temporarily in read only mode and not accepting new answers.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .