I think most here would agree that whenever someone asks Is this a scam, the answer is almost certainly, Yes, this is a scam.
Have there been any instances of questions like these where the answer was actually, No?
-
11Here's one: Is this $200 “welcome money” (from a major bank) some sort of scam? [Can't post as answer, auto-converted to comment.]– WBTJul 11, 2018 at 22:09
-
1@WBT why can't you post it as an answer? That is a great example!– BlackThornJul 12, 2018 at 15:15
-
3I did, and the SE platform software automatically converted it to a comment, and changed the nicely displaying title into just the link URL as part of that unwanted autoconversion.– WBTJul 12, 2018 at 15:38
-
3@WBT Huh, my guess is your answer was too short, but it's just a guess. Maybe if you tried filling it out more it wouldn't autoconvert.– BlackThornJul 12, 2018 at 15:40
-
Even if the answer is yes, it is still helpful to ask these questions because: 1. Others experiencing the same kind of scam things will recognize it if they search. 2. It´s helpful to understand how a specific scam works, to protect yourself against it.– DanielDec 13, 2019 at 22:52
Add a comment
|
5 Answers
It is very rare, but it does happen occasionally that an “Is this a scam?” question can be answered “No.”
A few examples:
Scam Potential: Images of receipts sent over email. In this question, the asker received an image of a receipt in an email. I answered that it was most likely just mistakenly sent to the wrong address.
An online casino owes me money and wants to pay with a wire transfer. Is this safe? Here, it is not exactly answered “no scam,” but the answer essentially boils down to the fact that it is potentially legitimate, and that while caution is needed, it isn’t necessarily a problem.
Is Amazon's offer of a $50 gift card a scam? The question is about a specific credit card incentive program, and although there are catches with these types of things, most people would not call them scams.
CitiBank CC application OP was confused by the request for additional details from a bank where she applied for a credit card.
If you look at the questions tagged scams, you’ll see that although many can be simply dismissed as an obvious scam, sometimes a situation is presented that requires a little more discussion.
Often, when someone asks one of these questions, someone will reply with “If you have to ask, then it is a scam.” However, when we look at enough of these questions, we find that it is not necessarily true.
-
3The other non-scam case I can think of, is "heir-finders". They are (usually) legitimate, but they can look very scammy. I couldn't find any questions about them, but I'm sure some will occur Mar 4, 2018 at 13:13
-
2
-
1Could you make this community wiki? I'd like to add money.stackexchange.com/q/101935/9083 to the answer.– gerritNov 13, 2018 at 11:06
-
@gerrit I really didn’t intend for this answer to become a list of every single “scam” question that is answered “no,” and I don’t think that this meta question is asking for one. The question here is “Have there been any?”, and the answer is “yes” with a few examples. I don’t think any more examples need to be added. Nov 13, 2018 at 12:22
-
1@BenMiller Yet it consistently seems novel: Comments with at least dozens of upvotes on that last one include: "wow, an 'is this a scam?' question that might not actually be a scam." and "This may be a first on this stack: a question posted under “scams” that turns out to NOT be a scam!"– WBTNov 14, 2018 at 15:13
Another highly popular question that turned out not to be a scam:
I'm supposedly eligible for an inheritance from a distant relative. Offer appears to be legitimate
Got $2 in the mail from the Pew Research Center, is this a scam?
Turns out, Pew Research indeed cold-mails people cash as an incentive to take part in surveys.
-
Apparently the US National Science Foundation does too, but they send checks.– WBTNov 25, 2019 at 16:59
This one sounds like a scam. How long until a Vending Machine pays itself back?
It as many of the classic parts of a well known scam, but it makes no sense that the company would do this to their employees. Although the group of current employees may already be victims and want to spread the pain.
I added the tag because there were enough red flags in the question to make we wonder. Sometimes the scam tag isn't added when the question is first written. I wonder if it has ever removed from a question?
answered Feb 24, 2018 at 11:56
-
Is there any evidence that it isn't a scam? The employer might be offering it to the employees, but it could just be the case of it being a relatively small company, the owner has been contacted by the vending company, and the owner wants to let the employees choose whether to have the vending machine in their canteen.– AndyTNov 25, 2019 at 13:46
I would add to the list: How scammy are cashback sites? asking about various cash-back sites which give users a small percentage of a purchase back as a rebate/credit in exchange for using an affiliate link. At least sometimes, it's not actually a scam.
