Look at university and college. They are about the same topic. Should they be merged?
4
-
Which one should "win"? :-) Maybe we can have a poll via two competing answers..– GS - Apologise to Monica ModOct 2 '20 at 17:42
-
@GS-ApologisetoMonica I've written an answer in favor of "university". :-)– FluxOct 3 '20 at 2:12
-
Sounds good - if someone wants to argue for "college" they can post an answer.– GS - Apologise to Monica ModOct 3 '20 at 10:44
-
Other tags should also be considered for merging with these: school, education, education-savings, tuition– Ben Miller - Remember MonicaOct 7 '20 at 12:28
Add a comment
|
On one hand, college has more questions than university. 97 questions vs. 12 questions.
On the other hand:
Few countries use "college" to refer to "university" (most notably the US). In most countries, colleges either do not have degree-awarding powers, are merely high schools, or are part of universities.
In any case, when speaking to a global audience, "college" is ambiguous whereas "university" is less so.
Therefore, I suggest that university wins.
Further reading:
The underlying problem is that most questions originate in the US, where "college" and "university" have the same meaning.
The secondary problem (a very common one on SE sites) is the poor tag data:
- college: Questions related to saving and paying for a college education
- university: [ empty ]
possibly because "college" can be used in different ways in different countries.
But both tags are far too specific for the questions being asked.
When one is saving for or paying off one's educational expenses, does it really matter what specific kind of institution it is?
Perhaps both tags should be replaced by:
- education: Questions related to saving and paying for post-secondary education
answered Oct 3 '20 at 17:53
-
2I think "education" might be misused for educational materials about investing.– FluxOct 3 '20 at 18:29
-
3
-
education is already a tag, and should probably also be merged with the other ones. Oct 7 '20 at 12:18
-
+1 for "education". I think that college, university, education-savings, school, and tuition should all be merged into this. Oct 7 '20 at 12:59